Dr. James Canton
Envisioning Stock Trading Where the Brokers Are 'Bots'
1![]()
Envisioning Stock Trading Where the Brokers Are 'Bots'
By Carol Alvarez Troy
During the severe plunge on Wall Street last month, some big brokers
couldn't get order confirmations for over two hours. Some agitated
customers couldn't even get their brokers on the telephone. And the
country's largest securities firms whittled away at small-customer good
will while the sinking market whittled away at their money.
James Canton served notice that new technologies sweeping the financial services
sector will “rock your world” in the next three to five years.
But
if you listen to one futurist, the days of the middleman broker are
numbered. In his view, Wall Street's huge army of stock brokers is
marching into a technological battle that could break their hold on the
little guy, because the small retail customer is no longer a sure bet
in the Internet era.
Last month, brokers were cautioned sharply
by James Canton, a San Francisco futurist, in a speech before the
Investment Management Consultants Association convention in Dallas.
Canton,
head of the Institute for Global Futures and managing director of a
high-tech consulting firm, Praxis, served notice that new technologies
sweeping the financial services sector will "rock your world" in the
next three to five years.
"We're not far from the idea of a broker in a box," he said.
Online
applications - like Datek's $9.99 online electronic trading, analyst
ratings and trading software - are revolutionizing the small customer's
power and access on Wall Street.Some Wall Street observers even
credited the small investor's new habit of "buying on the dip" with the
market's initial recovery from the 450-point drop in the Dow Jones
average earlier this month.
But according to Canton, 1997's
tantalizing online peek into behind-the-scenes market operations is
only the opening wedge of a power shift on Wall Street.
Within
three to five years, Canton projects deployment of "stock bots" - a
sort of trading Deep Blue supercomputer - available on call to
individuals. These technologies will help make the current advisory
role of stock broker obsolete, he believes.
Related Article
Confessions of an Online Stock Watcher
Today,
sophisticated computer programs help manage multibillion-dollar
portfolios for Wall Street brokerage houses and investment banks.
Tomorrow, Canton says, customers themselves will access such expert
programs directly rather than ask for help from a salesman-broker
trying to increase brokerage commissions.
Further, he says, software
makers exporting a "market in a box" will enable small markets like
Jakarta to go digital, along the lines of Nasdaq, for quick electronic
buying and selling.
The small investor will then claim a
lucrative front-row seat in a new cyberspace game played out across
worldwide financial markets.
Canton sketches out a futuristic
business trip five years hence: "Flying from Jakarta to San Francisco,
I configure my goals on my laptop and make an instantaneous buy."
"In
a five-minute window, I go between markets in Chile, London, Hong
Kong," he said. "The technology is opening tremendous opportunities for
dealing in a global digital economy."
Of course, the laptop stock bots of Canton's imagined business trip bear little resemblance to today's versions.
Various
programs now search out news and information on the Internet. But
smarter bots are being developed. Cambridge, England's CyberLife
Technology Ltd. supports engaging "bot" personalities that are
multiplying rapidly, driven by genetic algorithms.
Some experts in the software field maintain that Canton’s scenario is simply not possible in that time frame.
Pattie
Maes, known as Queen of the Bots among the international techno-elite,
founded and directs the Software Agents Group at the MIT Media Lab.
Maes lights up at the idea of a personal stock bot: "The London market
is all electronic," she said. Maes has already developed a new
shopping, negotiating bot marketed as Kasbah.
But Canton's
three-to-five year scenario calls for a true super-bot - not just a
Kasbah shopper - that can hook into global data flows to optimize the
small guy's investment goals.Ideally, Canton said, these personable
stock bots will help consumers make decisions, trade, negotiate,
invest, and pile up profits.
While acknowledging that financial
services companies will have to step lively to stay in the running for
the small customers' business, some experts in the software field
maintain that Canton's scenario is simply not possible in that time
frame.
"The software is not anywhere near that level of
sophistication," said Tandy Trower, who works with Web site builders
using Microsoft's software and runs Microsoft Agent development for the
software giant.
"But," Trower said, "there is room for agents (bots) to assist both (broker and client) in finding ways to analyze the data."
While
stressing the highly theoretical nature of such artificial intelligence
work, Eric Horvitz, who works in Microsoft Research's AI group, agreed
that stock brokers are already threatened.
Citing online
brokers, the high price of telephone trades with a broker, and online
financial research, Horvitz said "these better and better tools
continuously lower the differential between Joe Consumer and the Smith
Barney consumer (a brokerage firm with no online trading)." (Horvitz
noted that he often comes home from work to find his wife, an
accountant, on the computer, getting quotes from the Microsoft Investor
site.)
But is the death of the broker simply a figment of the
futurist's imagination? Not according to Canton. Data mining technology
is currently so sophisticated that a firm like Merrill Lynch could
electronically search through all their brokers' personal customer
portfolios today to create a fine-tuned investment strategy for each
customer. But will they?
Why should a retail brokerage house
theoretically pay a "$100,000 salary to a stock broker," Canton asked,
"when for under $50,000 they could create a minimal human interface for
their customers?"
But even Canton hasn't stamped and mailed out invitations to the brokers' funeral.
"Smart
financial services companies are reinventing the mission of the broker
- NOW," according to the consultant. "Traditionalists denying these
changes are going to miss the boat on the 21st century."
FOX News - Dark Times
1The Future of MegaCities
1 A transformation in cities is going on. Over 80% of the 6 billion people on the planet today are living in cities. By 2040, there will be over 8 billion. Over 100 new cities will be created within 25 years in China alone. Over 20 new Megacities will redefine the consumer marketplace and society. Most of these cities of over 8 million people each will be in the developing world. With the huge migration to cities of the global population, what challenges will these cities face? What are the opportunities and risks? How should global organizations prepare for the future of cities?This presentation examines the future of cities and the impact on the world’s markets, consumers, societies and population. Key trends from planetary management, building healthy cities, cities that think, innovation, and green urban sustainability will be analyzed. Challenges and opportunities to security, health care, transportation, water, energy and climate will affect the future of cities. Find out what the key trends are that will shape the future of cities in the 21st century.
Dr. James Canton
CEO
Institute for Global Futures
Read some Client Testimonials
Tech, and the Future of Finance
1
Tech, and the Future of Finance
Futurist James Canton offers predictions on how technology will impact CFOs in 2003 and beyond.
Marie Leone, CFO.com
While Gandalf and Dumbledore give moviegoers a spectacular dose of year-end wizardry and soothsaying, the editors of CFO.com thought finance executives might want their own glimpse of the future. To that end, CFO.com Senior Editor Marie Leone spoke with futurist and social scientist James Canton about emerging technologies - and how those systems will change corporate finance in the not-so-distant future.
For example, much of what the CIO knew last year, the CFO must know this year, opines Canton, who is the founder and CEO of the Institute for Global Futures, a San Francisco-based think tank and consultancy. Going forward, says Canton, CFOs will reinvent themselves and their career for the long run, and their success will be determined by what new things - outside of financial management - the finance chief is willing to learn.
Over the next few years, the CFO's technology purview will grow to include management of real-time reporting; cross-border transactions without boundaries; fast bandwidth; nanotechnologies; software agents that clone CFO decision making; and location-based marketing tied to GPS satellites.
Perhaps more interesting, executives will begin to see some of these technologies creep into their daily routine before King Aragon returns to Middle Earth or Harry Potter meets Sirus Black next holiday season.
CFO.com: Would you give a quick assessment of the current business technology environment?
James Canton: We are in the Middle Ages when it comes to the mature deployment of technology. This is just the beginning of the transformation of business led by innovation. The real productivity and competitive advantages are just emerging now.
CFO.com: Haven't we at least made it to the Age of Enlightenment?
Canton: We are on our way. However, think of it this way: 75 percent of the world's population has not made its first phone call; the Internet only reaches 500 million; less than 1 percent of all supply chains have been connected; and we don't have the wireless Web. What's more, half of all the products that will be sold in the next five years haven't been invented yet.
CFO.com: What will the ante be to stay in the game?
Canton: Over the next 3 to 5 years, senior executives will have to invest in smart information technology to establish a clear competitive advantage. Creating the real-time enterprise with a 360 degree view of all financial information, on-demand, is coming. My chief concern: whether companies will develop a capacity to anticipate future opportunities and risks.
CFO.com: Which transformational technology will CFOs test-drive first?
Canton: CFOs will gain the most from building financial systems that have complete financial knowledge transparency. In practical terms, financial managers will close the books, get an accurate cash picture, and identify and locate assets all in real-time. In addition, CFOs will use artificial intelligence (AI) for decision-support once the technology is embedded in back-end software. AI agents will retrieve internal and external data on a daily basis, to send, for example, automatic messages to notify the CFO if a particular budget is incomplete, or if too much cash is being is moved from a particular account.
CFO.com: Will these back-end systems be smart enough to sniff out accounting fraud?
Canton: If we program them that way. The software robots - fraud agents - will identify irregular accounting patterns. Whether the irregularity turns is intentional or just a mistake, is another matter. As more financial systems become connected in data warehouses, the use of agents will increase.
CFO: Won't companies need access to more bandwidth to serve these corporate technology needs?
Canton: Fast bandwidth will be mission-critical for running the enterprise. As more functions move to the Internet, fast bandwidth will be essential. Workers will need broadband access for everything from Web-based collaboration on projects to checking their 401(k) account. If fast reliable communication links via the Internet are not available, ROI will suffer.
CFO.com: Would you give an example of how technology might affect specific corporate finance functions?
Canton: They'll be some changes to treasury operations over the next few years. For instance, CFOs and treasurers will migrate to systems and gateways that capture, report and manipulate real-time data. This will give them more control over investments, asset allocations, human and capital resources, arbitrage techniques, and more. Also, much of the decision-making complexity - such as when to move cash or assets or when to execute a payment of Euros into British pounds - will be handled by an automated agent programmed with rules that mirror the company's risk tolerance and success parameters. Humans won't disappear. They'll do more, faster and effectively.
CFO.com: When will AI-based decision support systems hit the mainstream?
Canton: Within five years we'll witness the rise of the neural net, genetic algorithm, and expert systems that provide advice for CFOs and treasurers - such as what is the best play to make for an overnight investment. The systems will create "expert behavior" rules from massive databases that are filled with previous transaction data and outcomes. Eventually CFOs will use financial software agents to "clone" their expertise for true multi-tasking.
CFO.com: Will wireless devices figure into the financial function?
Canton: Yes. Here's one near-term example: A CFO is playing golf on a Sunday. An intelligent agent contacts the CFO's wireless device and signals that within the next two hours there is an opportunity to buy 100,000 sheets of copper at a Japanese auction. The agent has already checked the supply chain data and reports that this would be a good acquisition. With an authorization code and a finger print ID, the CFO places a bid for the copper sheets, and taps into his handheld device a ceiling price and other parameters. The agent does the rest and signals the CFO when, and if, the deal goes through.
CFO.com: So supply chain innovation is inevitable?
Canton: Every CFO - whether from a service or product company - must become savvy about supply chain innovation. In five years, everyone will be using end-to-end, Web-centric technology to accelerate the supply chain. However, the Web-based supply chain is not a breakthrough, it is simply a new commodity. The innovation will be next generation supply chains that are proactive, not reactive.
CFO.com: Will manufacturing economics change?
Canton: Yes, and real-time innovation and the advent of nanotechnology will change the economics of the day. Nanotech is a fundamental design science that manipulates matter at the atomic level. That's 100,000 times smaller then the head of a pin. This revolution will make Internet advances seem small. Applications are just emerging in the business sector. Look for an impact on energy, manufacturing and biotech. But eventually, manufacturing facilities that incorporate different small technologies will produce on-demand products in an inexpensive, flexible and rapid process. This is going to be big over the next decade.
CFO.com: How will nanotechnology alter manufacturing economics?
Canton: Imagine a nanochip that delivers over 50 gigahertz of speed with the processing power of 10 supercomputers that can be placed in a device that is smaller than a key chain - and is priced less than a quartz watch; or a super strong and inexpensive construction material that has the strength off steel yet the properties of plastic. Certain nanotechnologies will reduce the fabrication cost of computers by 50 percent, and decrease drug development costs by 70 percent. When real cost reductions for essential goods and services drop, it affects the quality of life. Development of new energy sources, driven by nanotech, could wean us off of oil in our lifetime.
CFO.com: In a work world filled with nanotechnology, real-time supply chains, and cross-border deals with no boundaries, what is the prognosis of the talent pool?
Canton: Human talent will be in demand. Currently, there are one million high-tech jobs in the U.S., and companies are unable to fill the vacancies. In five years, there will be two million high-tech jobs in the U.S. By 2010 the U.S. will have a shortfall of over ten million jobs, and not just high-tech. The talent wars of the 21st century have just begun. Every CFO should be concerned about this growing issue.
CFO.com: What effects will the shortage have on corporations?
Canton: As expected, salaries will rise as executives aim to acquire and retain experienced high-tech workers. The key question, however, will be how to do that. Do you move some operations off shore, to places like India where the talent pool is bigger? Do you set up a more flexible workplace to entice candidates? In a post September 11 environment, it is likely that an agreeable, flexible work place will become more important than money.
CFO.com: Are there any other human resources trends that CFOs should keep an eye on?
Canton: Biotech. New drugs and medical procedures will enhance human performance and longevity over the next five years. That means that the 78 million baby boomers - the company veterans - won't be retiring as planned. These older workers are the most experienced, and they will be the most coveted. As a result, staffing policies and procedures will be reworked to accommodate the 65-year-old-plus employees that are capable and willing to work much longer. We will need the aging boomers expertise in a world where the workforce is shrinking.
CFO.com: Let's jump to the future of corporate security. What do CFOs need to know about systems security?
Canton: The more things "get connected" the more potential there is for security risks. My advice is for CFOs to invest more in encryption, firewall, and other security technologies in 2003. Also, CFOs should understand the new definition of risk management, and redefine technology's role in making the enterprise secure. Too few CFOs understand this. Not enough money is being spent here. Terrorism that targets corporate financial infrastructure is next. Beware.
Another big issue will be to protect consumer privacy or risk losing their loyalty. Something companies cannot afford in a weak economy. I tell CFOs to outsource corporate security audits and plans. This is a very specialized area. Don't let the in-house IT team turn security into a life long project.
CFO.com: What are your views on the future of physical security?
Canton: CFOs should take a hard look at installing security that uses biometrics. At least 90 percent of the companies I work with are unprepared to upgrade physical security measure - too many CFOs are in denial about security precautions, even in light of September 11.
CFO.com: Will the CFO's role change over the next five years?
Canton: There will be a dramatic shift in the role of the CFO. The finance chief will emerge as the business forecaster - or futurist. In addition, more CFOs will step into the CEO role because of their holistic, yet anchored, view of the enterprise. Technology will enable this future, making the new-era CFO a key leader.
CFO.com: Any words of advice for CFOs about the new year?
Canton: If they haven't already, create a plan to monetize the value of information technology, rethink your role, create a future plan that is tech-enabled, learn to secure the enterprise, embrace the real-time enterprise, and get to know the blue-haired, body-pierced set that runs the IT department. It will make a difference.
FOX News - Crystal Ball
1Help Wanted: The Future of the Workforce
1One of the key defining resources that will define the winners and the losers in the 21st century economy will be workforce talent. This presentation reviews the emerging workforce trends and challenges that will impact organizations worldwide. The Labor Department data indicates that a workforce shortage is fast approaching that will influence every organization. Is your organization ready for the 21st century talent wars? The future workforce's demands for learning, information access, technology, compensation, benefits, power and participation will require a new human resource strategy ready for the future.
There will be more minorities, more women and more cultural diversity. The future workforce will dominate the landscape and competition for their services will be fierce. A labor shortage may become a crisis. Will you be ready to face the future? Workforce future changes will impact every organization's bottom line and the time to plan for these changes is now. Tune in to this keynote to discover what every business must know about the future workforce and how to compete.
Dr. James Canton
CEO
Institute for Global Futures
Read some Client Testimonials
The Future of Sales in a High Tech World
1
The Future of Sales Lead Management
Selling Power
Henry Canaday
July 2002
Managing Leads Means Learning All The Lessons
The Internet revolution hit a speed bump along with the economy in 2001. But experts are betting the pace will quicken again, after some painful lessons have been learned. And nowhere will both pace and lessons be more important than in managing leads. Sales managers have some especially critical challenges.
"The future of lead management will depend on sales managers and executives who are as technically savvy as today's Chief Information Officers (CIOs)," says James Canton, president of the Institute for Global Futures. Canton, a member of MIT's Media Lab Europe and an advisor to the National Science and Technology Council, says pure scale will be one powerful pressure for upgrading technical skills. "There will be new tools, including the next-generation Internet, applications for prospecting, direct marketing and delivery of offers for new products via electronic markets," he argues. "These will create more leads than even the best sales teams can personally deal with."
Fundamentally, it is the widening of the information highway that will enable these changes. "The next-generation Internet will be faster, more robust and more intelligent," Canton says. "The plumbing will get much better. So the sales manager of the future must integrate data mining and warehousing with use of the Internet for direct marketing by streaming video. Sales, marketing and technology will fuse to generate leads and translate them into customers."
How long will this take? The future is not far off, according to Canton. "By around 2005, a sales manager will have access to around 1 billion people and companies in 200 countries on the Internet."
Suppose you want to identify a critical mass of 1,000 new industrial customers for your newest product. Traditionally, companies looking for new leads could purchase lists, gather referrals, go to trade shows and so forth. By 2005, according to Canton, there will be a much better, faster way. A new tool, which Canton calls a 'Spider,' will conduct an intelligent search of the Internet to find, qualify and obtain suitable contact information on new leads. "A spider is a search engine, like Yahoo or Googol, but with embedded intelligence," Canton explains. "You will tell it, find me the best 20,000 leads for this product, and then report back."
The next step is a quick walk down the corridor to the marketing department. "You should already have told marketing that you are going to need a 30-second video to send your pitch electronically to the 20,000 leads the Spider found," Canton says.
Now technology begins to pay off. Direct mail traditionally yields returns of 1 to 3 percent. Video e-mail sent to a thoroughly qualified prospect list, Canton says, can generate much higher returns, up to 70 percent in some cases. "But let's assume you send videos out 20,000 and get back 3,000 indications of interest. Now you can go to your Customer Relationship Management system (CRM) for an agenting technology."
Come again. What's an agenting technology? By 2005, Canton says there will be something he calls a Sales Avatar. Basically, this is a highly sophisticated component of your website that can quickly and correctly answer, say, the top 50 questions interested prospects may have about your new product. The 3,000 interested prospects are directed to the Sales Avatar for an easy way to find out more about the product and how if might fit into their business. They are also given the option of contacting a live sales rep instead of the Avatar, or after they have exhausted its knowledge. "That's what you use your live salesforce for," Canton emphasizes.
Spiders and Avatars, well integrated with robust basic processes, could transform more than the selling function itself. Exploited to their full potential, they can transform entire companies. "Say top management is thinking about building a new product," Canton explains. "But before they build the product or license the rights, they want to know whether there are customers willing and committed to buy it. They turn to the sales manager to see if he can pre-sell the product to enough customers to justify production." And the tech-savvy sales manager turns to his Spider and Avatar to check out the market. Interested customers are given attractive discounts or other terms for an early commitment. "Say they commit by May 15, then you know you have the critical mass of leads and the digital cash will show up so that you have the money to finish production."
Suddenly, lead management is becoming a little more like company management.
Some of these more powerful tools are being put in place today. Companies that have shied away from data mining and warehousing will soon be able to outsource these sophisticated technical capabilities at reasonable costs. The Internet is rapidly expanding, especially outside the US, and getting much faster. The wireless Internet is coming, too. "We are very close to having prototype Spiders and Avatars," Canton says.
The hardest part of the future may be, as usual, preparing the people. How exactly do sales managers become CIOs? Fortunately, they will not have to learn Java programming to do their jobs. Canton says a lot of the technical messes that today's CIOs have to deal with will be largely solved shortly. "In two years, even the CIO's job will be much easier, or at least higher-level. Right now, they are dealing with chaos and confusion. That will soon be history."
And what sales execs will really have to know is how to use the new technologies to sell. That means knowing the capabilities of new tools and what's coming down the pike. It means being able to fit tools into sales strategies. And that will require knowing at least enough technical jargon to talk to the experts.
How do busy reps and sales managers get ready for this acceleration in high tech? Canton thinks there are plenty of ways to understand what you need to know without taking too much time. "If you want to take a course in technology, there are online courses you can do at home over the weekend," he notes. "There are books and periodical articles. You can hit the high-tech trade shows and question the vendors about their equipment. Ask them what their tools can do for selling and what's coming up next. I learn a huge amount from talking with IT vendors."
Sometimes, the answers may be right down the corridor. "You probably have people in your company who live and breathe this stuff," Canton says. "You know, the ones with the purple hair and nose rings. Talk to them."
Indeed, getting up to next-generation Internet speed should be no tougher than the challenges effective sales forces met throughout in the 1990s. "Reps had to learn how to use sales force automation tools like ACT and Goldmine," Canton notes. "They have learned to use e-mail and cell phones. In a few years, that stuff will be like the Middle Ages."
Canton thinks the current slow economy may just be ideal for doing the homework that will bring business in the next up-cycle. And the technology is coming very fast. "It will become standard long before the first baby boomers retire," Canton emphasizes. "It's coming and it's doable."
Innovation and the Future
1Page 9 of 15
